| Notes |
The epic 30-year bromance of billionaire CEOs Larry Ellison and Marc Benioff
Eugene Kim Aug 12, 2015, 8:00 AM
Benioff Salesforce Ellison Oracle
Mike Nudelman/Business Insider
Oracle CEO Larry Ellison and Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff’s on and off relationship makes for one of the most interesting storylines in Silicon Valley.
Ellison took Benioff under his wing and turned him into a star executive by the age of 26. But after spending 13 years at Oracle, Benioff launched his own company called Salesforce in 1999, becoming one of Oracle’s biggest rivals in the cloud software space.
The two love to trash talk each other’s company, often getting into public feuds over their businesses. But some argue they’re still good friends, and have great respect for each other.
Ellison is the fifth richest man in the world with a net worth of over $54 billion. Benioff is worth about $3.6 billion.
Here’s a summary of the epic 30-year love-hate relationship between the two business titans:
Benioff started working at Oracle at age 23. He left a strong impression immediately, winning Oracle's Rookie of the Year award that year.
The Oracle logo is seen on its campus in Redwood City, California June 15, 2015. REUTERS/Robert Galbraith
The Oracle logo is seen on its campus in Redwood City Thomson Reuters
Three years later, Benioff became Oracle's youngest VP at the age of 26. By then, he was already a star executive, making over $300,000 a year.
Marc Benioff
Salesforce.com CEO Marc Benioff Kenneth Yeung - www.thelettertwo.com
During his 13 years at Oracle, Benioff became one of Ellison’s closest friends and most trusted lieutenant. Carlye Adler writes in Fortune, “They sailed to the Mediterranean on Ellison's yacht, visited Japan during cherry blossom season, spent Thanksgiving together, and even double-dated.”
ellison yacht
Reuters/Robert Galbraith
Source
In many ways, Benioff was similar to Ellison: tall, charismatic, technologically savvy, and a gifted speaker. As former Oracle president Ray Lane once said, "Marc would get people believing in his vision and supporting whatever project he wanted to do…That’s Larry…Marc’s one of Larry’s favorite children.”
larry ellison
Michael Bradley/Getty Images)
Source
In fact, the two were so close that there were all kinds of rumors about their relationship. "It's weird…People said I was related to Larry Ellison...that I was his nephew, or that Larry was my babysitter, or he mowed my parents' lawn,” Benioff told Fortune. NetSuite’s Zach Nelson said, “We heard that [Benioff] washed Larry’s car as a child.”
larry ellison
Ezra Shaw/Getty Images
Source
When Benioff first started building Salesforce in 1999, he was still working at Oracle. He says Ellison was always supportive of his outside endeavor, giving him permission to split work at Salesforce in the morning and at Oracle in the afternoons. Ellison even let Benioff take a 6 month sabbatical before starting Salesforce.
Marc Benioff
Salesforce.com CEO Marc Benioff Salesforce.com
Source
After 90 days of running Salesforce, Ellison suggested Benioff take a leave of absence from Oracle, even offering to have him back if Salesforce didn’t work out. “He was my mentor for more than a decade as well as a close friend,” Benioff wrote about Ellison in his book, “Behind the Cloud.”
A Salesforce sign is seen as attendees make their way through Moscone Center during the company's annual Dreamforce event, in San Francisco, REUTERS/Robert Galbraith
Salesforce sign is seen as attendees make their way through Moscone Center during the company's annual Dreamforce event, in San Francisco Thomson Reuters
Source
Ellison even invested the first $2 million in Salesforce and joined its board of directors as well. He told Benioff not to take more than 3 people from Oracle to Salesforce when he left the company.
ellison
Kimberly White / Getty
Source
But their relationship took a quick turn in 2000 when Benioff found out that Oracle had secretly started its own CRM service that directly competed with Salesforce. Benioff wanted Ellison to leave Salesforce’s board immediately, but Ellison refused to quit. Ellison told Benioff, “It would be much cooler if you fired me.” (because that way Ellison would get to keep his Salesforce shares).
shadows
A pair of men carry on a conversation in the shadows. REUTERS/Staff
Source
This created a lot of media buzz, which Benioff said was “the greatest thing that ever happened to us.” Ellison eventually resigned from Salesforce’s board, but Benioff let Ellison keep his stock and options. “I can say I’m the only person who fired Larry Ellison,” Benioff told Fortune.
fired layoffs let go box leaving work
Reuters
Source
Benioff still likes to call Ellison his mentor. One of the books Ellison urged Benioff to read is Sun Tzu’s “The Art of War.” Benioff once said, “We believe in ‘The Art of War’, in that we are trying to get our competitors to attack us with angry, virulent energy.”
sun tzu
Wikimedia Commons/Hinio
Source
Both Benioff and Ellison also have great interest in Zen Buddhism. “I’ve been in Zen monasteries meditating with Larry in Kyoto,” he once said.
Kyoto Kiyomizy temple Sunset
Shutterstock
Source
For years, the two engaged in public spats, openly bashing each other’s companies. Ellison repeatedly played down the growth of Salesforce’s cloud software, dismissing it as hype and an “itty bitty application” mostly running on Oracle’s databases, while Benioff shrugged off Oracle’s software as “false cloud.”
cloud
Nicholas Hunt/PatrickMcMullan.com
Source
Perhaps the peak point of their feud came in 2011 when Ellison booted Benioff from speaking at Oracle’s OpenWorld show at the last minute. It was perceived as Ellison’s way of humiliating Benioff for publicly making fun of his keynote speech and Oracle’s cloud product.
marc benioff hawaii
Justin Sullivan/Getty Images, Bing Maps
Source
Benioff said he thinks Oracle booted him because they were afraid he'd give a more entertaining speech than Ellison, telling the Times: "You don’t have somebody over to your house to tell better jokes than you." Benioff ended up giving a speech at a nearby hotel instead.
Marc Benioff Iron Throne
Marc Benioff posed in front a replica Iron Throne from the Game of Thrones premier Marc Benioff
Source
But in 2013, peace broke out between the two when Oracle and Salesforce announced a strategic partnership. In what was one of the most surprising press conferences ever, Ellison and Benioff suddenly had only nice things to say about each other.
handshake bigger
Flickr
Source
Benioff said during the call, “Oracle has been there with us when we have had problems. I also just wanted think Larry as well. (Oracle is) always there for us whenever we need them. They are a true partner, they've always been a true partner.”
marc benioff
Robert Galbraith/Reuters
Source
Ellison said in response: "I'm looking forward to working with Marc and Salesforce for years to come, to tap on some of these exciting challenges and help the future arrived a little bit sooner than it otherwise would."
larry ellison, oracle, sv100 2015
Oracle Corp Chief Executive Larry Ellison introduces the Oracle Database In-Memory during a launch event at the company's headquarters in Redwood Shores, California June 10, 2014. Ellison on Tuesday launched the "in-memory" technology for speeding up data analysis in a bid to beef up demand for his company's software products. The in-memory features, which Oracle has been talking about for months, allow for faster database queries and transactions as companies collect, store and analyze growing amounts of information across the Internet. REUTERS/Noah Berger Noah Berger/Reuters
Source
In a follow up interview at TechCrunch Disrupt, Benioff admitted, “He’s my mentor. He was our first investor and first board member. There is no one I’ve learned more from than Larry Ellison.”
Marc Benioff talking
Salesforce.com CEO Marc Benioff Business Insider/TechCrunch Disrupt/screen capture
Source
But things have been devolving again recently, and the two appear to be back at it again. In a recent earnings call, Benioff slammed Oracle again, calling its “Fusion” applications “Confusion.”
mark benioff, salesforce, sv100 2015
SAN FRANCISCO, CA - SEPTEMBER 19: Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff delivers the keynote address during the Dreamforce 2012 conference at the Moscone Center on September 19, 2012 in San Francisco, California. A reported 90,000 people registered to attend the cloud computing industry conference Dreamforce 2012 that runs through September 21. (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images) Justin Sullivan/Getty
Source
It’s unclear what the real relationship between the two is truly like behind the scenes, but some of people who know both Ellison and Benioff say they still have great respect for each other.
Benioff Salesforce Ellison Oracle
Mike Nudelman/Business Insider
NEWSLETTER
Start your day with a morning cheat sheet. Sign up for 10 Things in Tech You Need To Know.
Email address
Email address
By clicking ‘Sign up’, you agree to receive marketing emails from Business Insider as well as other partner offers and accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
SEE ALSO: Salesforce's most successful salesman made tons of money by following this secret playbook
|